Blog

3 Common Nonprofit Marketing Pitfalls (& How to Solve Them!)

At one time or another, most nonprofits have fallen victim to some kind of marketing mistake, whether they’re fledgling organizations or large nonprofits with established brands. When your organization wants and needs to focus on mission-critical activities first, marketing efforts can sometimes fall by the wayside.

Fortunately, it’s possible to overcome and learn from your mistakes to create more effective and impactful marketing campaigns. In this guide, we’ll discuss three common pitfalls to watch out for, as well as some ways to avoid those issues.

1. Lack of focus.

If your nonprofit does not have a clearly defined focus for your marketing efforts, your campaigns can feel disjointed, lack cohesion, or even confuse supporters. 

Your messages could go ignored by most of your audience, meaning that you’ll miss out on donations and the chance to acquire new supporters. Because it can be challenging for your accounting team to allocate funding toward marketing efforts, it’s essential to avoid wasting resources.

How can you overcome this challenge?

Before you launch your next marketing campaign, try these tips:

Review your mission statement. Your mission statement should serve as a single source of truth that guides your strategies and messaging—check in with it frequently to keep your focus tight.

Keep branding consistent. Develop a brand guide that details your brand colors, fonts, logo, and the types of imagery you will use to ensure visual cohesion across your marketing materials. 

Define your audience. Knowing why your supporters engage with your nonprofit, their involvement history, and their other interests will help you make personalized appeals that ultimately earn more donations.

Write out your goals. Each campaign should have a clear focus or a primary objective to work toward, such as increasing your organization’s total number of supporters. 

Taking these extra steps to refine your point of focus will help to streamline your campaign and yield a more compelling marketing message.

2. Neglecting valuable data insights.

Every time your nonprofit makes a social media post or sends a marketing email, you receive a wealth of information about the supporters who engage with that content. However, many organizations make the mistake of storing this data in a file that is rarely reviewed or disregarding it altogether.

How can you overcome this challenge?

Rather than ignoring these impact measurements, here are some ways to make the most of this information:

Develop an attribution strategy. Choose an attribution model (or models) (e.g., first-touch, last-touch, or multi-touch) that will tell you which channels captured supporters’ attention and which motivated them to give. 

Identify key metrics. Determine which metrics relate to your goals and prioritize analyzing those. Keep in mind that your direct mail campaign will have a different set of metrics from your email campaign, for example.

Create data-driven content. After taking the time to analyze and glean insights from your data, put your findings into action by creating content shaped by those insights.

Be diligent about collecting and analyzing marketing data. Over time, you’ll be able to identify patterns in your data and gain insight into your supporters’ preferences and giving behaviors.

3. Having tech that doesn’t work for you.

Any marketing tools your nonprofit uses should make the process easier, but many organizations end up with a tech stack that hinders them instead. This leads to wasting your budget on unused software and sacrificing the efficiency you could have with tools that work for you.

How can you overcome this challenge?

Perform a regular audit of all of your tools and services to determine which ones you could stand to part with. Start by creating a list of “needs” that contains all of the functions you need to keep going. Then, create a list of “wants” that are nice to have, but not absolutely necessary. 

If you’re unsure about which tools you need to leverage, here are some that you’ll likely find most useful:
-Content management system (CMS)
-Email marketing platform
-Social media management tools
-Graphic design software
-Video and photo editing tools
-Analytics software

After a few campaigns, you may find that specialized tools like text-to-give software or custom website plugins are crucial for your nonprofit. But stripping your tech stack down to its skeleton first will help you develop a strong foundation of essential tools.

Overcoming these marketing mistakes only takes a little time and effort on your nonprofit’s part, but it can hold significant benefits like reaching new donors and boosting revenue.